So far, twenty states have implemented mandatory body mass index, or BMI, testing in their schools, preschool and up. The BMI test in and indicator of whether a child is overweight or obese. Once the test is done, the school sends a letter to the parents informing them of the results. If the test comes out negative, the parents get a letter and a plethora of information explaining how they can help their child eat healthy. The program has received negative and positive reviews from parents and professionals.
Since 2003, each year there are a few parents every year who feel like the program is harmful to kids that receive these “fat letters.” According to registered dietitian, Lauren Schmitt, it’s just the opposite. Her goal is to let parents know in a gentle fashion that their children need help, help that can be found in the “ton of handouts” she sends to the parents. She hopes to empower and educate parents through the program.
Michelle Healy, a health and wellness reporter, points out that there are risks. “Adolescents who were once overweight or obese are at high risk of developing an eating disorder.” Not only are these children at risk of eating disorders, but the letters can also harm their mental health. Statics point out even at a young age, kids worry and stress about physical appearance. Since the kids get tested all at once, bullies are able to get information to use against their victims, as well.
Some parents think the program is helpful, but think the schools could go about it differently. Mrs. Sabrina made a suggestion: “I think it’s a good idea to prevent and control obesity, but it would be better if the schools send the letter to the parent’s personal email instead of a letter that goes home with the kid. That way, the kid doesn’t have to feel pressured to show their results to others.” Mary Welch, a parent of two, makes another valid point. “If my child has to get tested, wouldn’t it make sense to send the BMI test to the school’s staff as well?”
Some state lawmakers are considering banning the fat letters from the schools based on the information received from the Department of Public Health. The program has good intentions, but it seems to have gone the wrong direction. Hopefully, the programs can be improved to avoid some of the negative consequences.
